When looking for my first Tudor, my requirements were simple: 37-40mm in diameter, a maximum lug-to-lug of 47mm, a bracelet, and a comfortable fit. During my initial visit to the boutique, I was recommended the Black Bay 54 since it fulfilled most of my criteria off the bat.
Two months later, I returned, ready to purchase the watch. I tried on a few other pieces out of curiosity - the Black Bay 58 GMT, the Black Bay Chrono and the Black Bay 58 with the 925 sterling case. Then the associate asked me if I had tried on any of the Professional models and I said no, I didn't even know they existed in Tudor's lineup. It was then I came face to face with the Tudor Pelagos in 39mm.
I tried it on, and the Black Bay 54, and then the Pelagos again. I couldn't decide between them. My associate deftly stepped in and said, "Take the Pelagos, trust me. You'll like it I promise." I wasn't entirely convinced, especially because of how the case sat on my six-inch (15.2cm) curved wrist. After another ten minutes of thinking bordering on analysis paralysis, I picked the Pelagos, the watch that wasn't even on my mind to begin with.
It's been a year since I've bought the watch, and looking back, I wonder why I even questioned it. I have taken this watch to pool parties, on my travels, hauling boxes when I was helping people move, barbecues, even watch events. There were times people thought I was wearing a Rolex, only to be surprised it was a Tudor instead. It's been the watch that has survived high-velocity acquisitions, other contenders for the top prize of the Top Tool Watch, but it has stayed the course. It's robust but light, and the black dial and bezel against the titanium case and bracelet give it a look that can be almost stealthy to non watch people. Also, the Tudor T-fit clasp is one of the best in terms of getting a good fit whether in the heat of summer or cool of winter.
Is it the prettiest Tudor? No. But is it the tool watch for me? In a heartbeat.